A contemporary romantic comedy about the universal quest for that one true love. All Over That Guy, centers on an unlikely pair of two twenty-somethings, Eli (Dan Bucatinsky) and Tom (Richard Ruccolo), who are thrown together by their respective best friends. They do everything they can to not fall for each other, but ultimately it's the small moments of truth - the talk among trusted friends and the fear between new lovers - that the two ultimately find their way to a love that will last.